Peer review (target journal · 5 reviewers · editorial decision)

Journal-style peer review of a manuscript, thesis or dissertation draft the user attaches (PDF, DOCX, HWP or Markdown) — also the skill for "review my paper / 논문 초안 검토해줘" with no journal named — looks up the journal's aims & scope and submission rules, gathers the journal's recent comparable papers, runs deterministic checks (rules, reference registry, recomputed statistics), has five reviewer personas (journal fit · methodology · domain expert · broader perspectives · devil's advocate) score and comment, and a handling editor issue the decision (Accept / Minor Revision / Major Revision / Reject), a prioritized revision guide and recommended journals.

Keypeer-review
TypeWorkflow skill
DomainPeer review
Slash command/peer-review

How to run it

Type the slash command in the composer followed by your request, or describe what you need in plain language — the skill is selected automatically.

/peer-review <your request>

Called by

← All method skills